diff --git a/Content/Items/Weapons/Geltana.cs b/Content/Items/Weapons/Geltana.cs
index 1341a41..19d35be 100644
--- a/Content/Items/Weapons/Geltana.cs
+++ b/Content/Items/Weapons/Geltana.cs
@@ -36,8 +36,7 @@ namespace continuity.Content.Items.Weapons
             Recipe recipe = Recipe.Create(ModContent.ItemType<Geltana>());
             recipe.AddIngredient(ItemID.Katana, 1);
             recipe.AddIngredient(ModContent.ItemType<ExquisiteGel>(), 8);
-            // TODO(midnadimple): Replace torch with coal when we implement that
-            recipe.AddIngredient(ItemID.Torch, 20);
+            recipe.AddIngredient(ItemID.Coal, 10);
             recipe.AddTile(TileID.Solidifier);
             recipe.AddTile(TileID.Anvils);
             recipe.Register();